Splitting from the main topic here
as it is more specific.
I basically agree with your arguments, however…
… IMHO gut feeling (we should all consider) per se is shaped by personal experience and for me it was different as I was-am part of many different web forums and now Discourse instances, that have hugely different dynamics, depending on both group and personal dynamics… Those packed with introverts are often very low in volume and almost no incentive for proactive shaping of forum (still useful but just not as organic in structure). Here I would offer more, knowing that people did not ask and might not proactively ask often.
This is also very subjective what is useful or not, but maybe of less relevance as no resource is ‘wasted’ if extra is done but not used.
Current state of affairs is:
- Site Feedback|1 (now I am adding extra)
- RIPE Atlas|16
- RIPE 85|6
IMHO the Uncategorised should be at least 80% categorised to get close to second and third best No?