I come in search of information. As part of a research project, we would like to perform DNS measurements that require to use the Extended Client Subnet option of DNS (ECS-DNS) and Google Public DNS resolver.
I could not find information related to those two topics, it is possible? If yes, sorry in advance that I missed the information. If no… well, thank you anyway!
*EDIT: So sorry, I just realised the resolver can be specified in the target parameter. My question is only on the topic of ECS-DNS.
Thanks for taking the time to answer and for pointing out this parameter!
Sadly we would like to inject an arbitrary client subnet within the DNS request (if you are familiar with the option). A bit like what is possible with the ZDNS tool.
The idea behind that is to get the response for a domain name for virtually any /24 subnet.
I guess this could be a great add-on for DNS measurements.
But not for now apparently, thanks anyway!
Hi Hugo, I can see the appeal for a researcher to be able to use “virtually any /24 subnet” But it does sound less attractive from the perspective of operators of those networks. Can you evaluate what the benefits of this feature would be for these network operators?
Haha, that, I can understand. I am biased by my own interests…
Considering the increase of ECS-DNS amount of traffic and its important role in the context of large public DNS revolvers (e.g. Google Public DNS), I think that the ability for ISPs to evaluate the impact of this option on client’s redirection is worth of interest.
While saying that, I also realise that this evaluation can be made from a single vantage point (without requiring RIPE Atlas infra). Our use-case is…very specific to say the least!
But it does sound less attractive from the perspective of operators of those networks. Can you evaluate what the benefits of this feature would be for these network operators?